Writers International Edition

Articles

The Wisdom Beyond Knowing: Exploring the Kenopanishad and Ishopanishad

The Upanishads occupy a distinctive place in the intellectual and spiritual heritage of India. They represent a sustained inquiry into the nature of existence, consciousness, knowledge and the relationship between the individual self and the ultimate reality. Composed in an age when philosophical inquiry was closely connected with contemplative practice, these texts examine questions that continue to engage the human mind: What gives life its vitality? What lies behind perception and thought? What is the nature of the self? How should one live in the world while understanding the reality that extends beyond it?

Among the principal Upanishads, the Kenopanishad and the Ishopanishad offer two complementary approaches to these questions. The Kenopanishad investigates the source of consciousness and the limitations of ordinary knowledge. The Ishopanishad explores the presence of the divine in all existence and examines how this understanding should influence human conduct. Together, they provide a philosophical framework that connects self-knowledge with an understanding of the world.

The Kenopanishad: Discovering the Source Behind Consciousness

The Kenopanishad begins with a question that establishes the direction of its entire inquiry. The Sanskrit word Kena means ‘by whom’ or ‘by what’. The opening verse asks:

By whom is the mind directed towards its objects? By whose command does the vital breath function? At whose prompting does speech arise? What divine principle directs the eyes and ears?

These questions take the reader beyond the familiar functioning of the human faculties. The mind thinks, the eyes perceive, the ears hear and speech communicates. Yet the Upanishad asks what makes these functions possible in the first place. It directs attention towards the principle that enables every form of perception without itself becoming an ordinary object of perception.

The second verse introduces one of the most significant ideas in Indian philosophical thought: Brahman is the ear of the ear, the mind of the mind, the speech of speech and the life of life. The expression does not describe another physical organ or an additional mental faculty. It points towards the fundamental consciousness through which all faculties become capable of functioning.

This distinction has profound implications. Human beings generally identify knowledge with what the senses perceive and what the intellect can understand. The Kenopanishad questions the completeness of this approach. If the mind is itself directed by a deeper principle, can that principle be fully understood through the mind? If the senses depend upon something beyond their own operations, can that reality be grasped through sensory experience alone?

The Upanishad suggests that Brahman cannot be approached as an ordinary object of knowledge. It is not something that the intellect can possess or describe completely. Its teaching is expressed through a striking paradox: it is known by those who understand that it cannot be known in the conventional sense, while those who believe that they have completely understood it have not truly comprehended its nature.

This does not dismiss intellectual inquiry. Rather, it establishes the limits of intellectual knowledge and invites a more profound awareness.

The teaching is further developed through the episode of the Yaksha, a mysterious being who appears before the gods after their victory over opposing forces. The gods initially attribute their triumph to their own power. The mysterious presence challenges their assumption. Agni and Vayu, representing the powers of fire and wind, are unable to demonstrate their strength before the unknown being. Indra approaches and discovers that the mysterious presence has disappeared. Uma Haimavati then reveals to him that the being was Brahman, through whose power the gods had achieved their victory.

This narrative conveys an important philosophical insight. The powers that human beings admire and claim as their own are dependent upon a reality greater than themselves. Recognition of that reality requires humility. Knowledge becomes meaningful when it leads beyond the limitations of individual pride and self-importance.

The Kenopanishad therefore remains relevant to contemporary life, particularly in an age that places considerable confidence in scientific achievement, technological advancement and intellectual capability. These developments have expanded human understanding of the external world. The Upanishad invites an additional inquiry into the nature of the consciousness through which such understanding becomes possible.

The Ishopanishad: Recognising the Divine Presence in All Existence

The Ishopanishad begins with a declaration that offers a distinctive understanding of the relationship between the individual and the universe:

Ishavasyam idam sarvam yat kincha jagatyam jagat.

All that exists in this changing universe is pervaded by the Lord.

The opening statement establishes the philosophical foundation of the text. The divine is not confined to a distant realm or restricted to a particular form of worship. Its presence extends throughout existence. The world, with its innumerable forms of life and movement, is understood in relation to this underlying reality.

This understanding has significant consequences for the way human beings perceive ownership, material possession and their relationship with the natural world.

The opening verse continues by teaching that one should enjoy or sustain life through renunciation, without coveting what belongs to another. Renunciation here is not necessarily an instruction to abandon all worldly responsibilities. It concerns the transformation of one’s relationship with possession and desire. When existence is recognised as pervaded by a reality beyond individual ownership, the impulse to accumulate and possess loses its absolute authority.

The Ishopanishad also addresses the relationship between knowledge and action. Its second verse declares that one may aspire to live a full life through the performance of one’s duties. This teaching establishes a significant principle: spiritual understanding need not require withdrawal from all worldly activity. Action can become part of a meaningful life when it is performed with the right understanding.

The Upanishad proceeds to examine the distinction between ignorance and knowledge, while cautioning against an incomplete understanding of either. Its discussion suggests that knowledge and ignorance have different consequences, yet a comprehensive understanding must recognise the limitations of an exclusive dependence on either. The text also explores the relationship between what is manifest and what is unmanifest, inviting the seeker to consider reality beyond the immediately visible world.

One of its most profound teachings appears in the verse that describes the wise person who sees all beings in the Self and the Self in all beings. Such a person does not experience the same divisions that ordinarily produce fear, alienation and hostility.

This vision has an ethical dimension. When the same underlying reality is recognised in all beings, compassion and respect become natural expressions of understanding. The relationship between human beings, other forms of life and the natural world acquires a deeper significance.

In this respect, the Ishopanishad offers philosophical foundations for a way of living that values restraint, responsibility and reverence for existence. Its teachings remain particularly meaningful in a world confronting environmental degradation, excessive consumption and the consequences of human disregard for the interconnectedness of life.

Two Upanishads, One Continuing Inquiry

Although the Kenopanishad and Ishopanishad approach philosophical inquiry from different directions, their teachings converge upon a central understanding of existence.

The Kenopanishad asks what makes consciousness and perception possible. It directs the seeker towards the reality that stands behind the functioning of the mind and senses. The Ishopanishad examines the implications of recognising that reality throughout the universe. It connects spiritual understanding with the manner in which one lives, acts and relates to other beings.

One turns the inquiry inward, towards the source of awareness. The other extends that understanding to the entire field of existence.

Together, they invite a movement from intellectual curiosity towards deeper comprehension. They ask the individual to reconsider familiar assumptions about identity, possession, achievement and the boundaries of personal existence. Their significance lies not merely in the philosophical propositions they present, but also in the questions they leave with the reader.

These questions have not lost their relevance with the passage of centuries. The human mind continues to seek explanations for consciousness, the nature of reality and the purpose of existence. The Upanishads approach these questions through a language of inquiry, reflection and contemplation that encourages readers to examine their own understanding.

Bringing Ancient Wisdom into Contemporary Verse

The continuing relevance of the Upanishads also depends upon the ways in which their teachings reach successive generations of readers. Translation plays an important role in this process. When philosophical works move from Sanskrit into another language, the translator must engage with both the meaning of the original text and the expressive possibilities of the receiving language.

Poetry offers a distinctive medium for this engagement. Its rhythm, imagery and compressed expression can bring philosophical ideas into a form that encourages contemplation while preserving their intellectual depth.

It is within this literary tradition that Dr. Srilakshmi M. Adhyapak’s forthcoming book, Kenopanishad and Ishopanishad in Verse, assumes its significance. Published by Writers International Edition as part of its Divine Dialogues series, the book brings two important Upanishadic texts into English verse.

Dr. Srilakshmi M. Adhyapak is a distinguished interventional cardiologist who serves as Professor and Head of the Department of Cardiology at St. John’s Medical College Hospital, Bengaluru. Alongside her medical profession, she has maintained a sustained interest in poetry, drawing inspiration from nature, philosophy and mythology. Her literary works include Ramayana and Other Poems, A Magical Refraction and Other Poems, The Song Divine: The Bhagavad Gita in Verse and Kathopanishad in Verse.

Her engagement with India’s philosophical and spiritual literature continues through this new volume. By presenting the Kenopanishad and Ishopanishad in verse, she brings their questions and insights into an English poetic form, offering readers another way to approach these enduring texts.

The book also contributes to the larger purpose of the Divine Dialogues series, which seeks to make India’s philosophical heritage accessible through literary interpretation.

An Invitation to Contemplation

The Kenopanishad and Ishopanishad offer readers an opportunity to reconsider the relationship between consciousness, existence and human responsibility. Their teachings address the source of awareness, the presence of the divine in the universe and the ethical implications of recognising the interconnectedness of all life.

Their importance does not depend upon the period in which they were composed. They continue to speak to the questions that accompany human existence across generations.

Kenopanishad and Ishopanishad in Verse by Dr. Srilakshmi M. Adhyapak invites contemporary readers into this continuing philosophical conversation. Through poetry, it brings the wisdom of two revered Upanishads into a form that can be read, reflected upon and revisited.

The inquiry begins with a simple question: By whose direction does the mind think? It gradually extends towards a larger understanding of existence itself. Between these two movements lies the enduring wisdom of the Upanishads, inviting every reader to look beyond the familiar and examine the foundations of life and consciousness.

The Wisdom Beyond Knowing: Exploring the Kenopanishad and Ishopanishad Read More »

A Few Drops of Raita: Why Empathy Toward the People Who Serve Us Matters

As we entered the restaurant, nearly every table was taken. It was lunchtime, and I had never seen a restaurant so full on an ordinary afternoon. The place served traditional Andhra food and had become famous for it, with celebrities among its visitors and videos of their meals travelling widely online. I was excited to be there, and glad to be with a friend from Andhra who is particular about hygiene, since the restaurant looked well kept. The people serving us were warm in a way that did not feel rehearsed, every one of them smiling, and I understood quickly why the place was so highly reviewed.

Each dish was served separately by a different person. When a man came with the raita, he said the word and placed it on my friend’s banana leaf in the same motion. She had already started to say no. A few drops lay on the leaf. Her anger was immediate and far larger than the cause. The man apologised several times in a low voice, and the apology made no difference to her. He went away, finally returned with a tissue, and wiped even the faint trace of raita from the leaf, bending over it while she went on looking at him with displeasure.

If it had been another kind of incident, I would have accepted it and moved on. My friend had every right to refuse the raita and ask for a fresh leaf. What I could not set aside was the manner. A man who stands in that room for hours so that his household can manage its month was being made to feel small over a few drops of curd. Somehow, even today, days after the incident, I could not stop thinking about it.

Empathy is often confused with sympathy. Sympathy is a feeling offered from a distance, a brief sadness about someone’s circumstances. Empathy asks us to come closer, to stand for a moment in the other person’s position and ask what the day looks like from there. From where the man with the bowl stood, the day looked like this: hours on his feet, a room that never stops calling, a smile he had to keep in place whatever the mood of the customers, a livelihood that depends on that smile, and a hundred chances every hour to make a mistake that a crowd will notice. A spoon moved a second too early. That was the whole offence.

The most important fact about that moment was that he could not answer. A server in a full restaurant has no room to defend himself. If he explains, he risks seeming rude. If he argues, he risks his job. So he apologises, again and again, and takes whatever is given. Anger moves downhill with very little effort, and it flows most freely toward people who cannot send any of it back. For this reason, the way we treat those who cannot answer us tells more about our character than the way we treat those who can. A person who is courteous to the manager and curt to the waiter has shown which of the two behaviours is real.

None of this is limited to restaurants. The same position is held by the delivery rider waiting at the gate in the heat, the security guard we do not greet, the domestic worker whose small mistake we remember for days, the driver, the sweeper, the clerk behind the counter, the attendant in a hospital corridor. Their work holds up the comfort of our days and is noticed only when something goes wrong, and then it is noticed loudly. Each of them has learned to absorb the irritation of strangers as part of the job. Most of us have never counted how much of it we have handed out.

It is worth asking why empathy fails us so often in these moments. Usually it is because we are absorbed in our own hunger, our own hurry, our own bad day, and the person in front of us shrinks into a function. He becomes the service rather than a human being delivering it. Once that happens, the mistake of a second feels like an insult, and the reaction grows to match. Nobody decides to be cruel. We stop seeing the person for a moment, and the cruelty follows without being invited.

Cruelty and kindness both travel. A man scolded in front of a full room at noon takes that scolding home in the evening. It enters his tiredness, his patience with his own children, the way he sleeps. The customer who raised her voice at the table will probably never know where it ended up. We tend to imagine our anger as an event that begins and finishes at the table. It does not finish. It moves on through the person who received it into rooms we will never see.

This is no argument against standards. Hygiene matters, and so does the right to refuse what we do not want. A customer can reject a dish, ask for a clean leaf, or complain to the manager in a firm voice. Firmness and cruelty are different things. A calm sentence, please change the leaf, would have settled the matter in seconds, and everyone in that restaurant would have complied. What makes the difference is whether the person on the other side is still a person while we make our point.

Part of the problem is the habit of believing that payment buys everything. When we pay for a meal, we are entitled to the food we ordered and to reasonable service. We are not entitled to diminish the dignity of the person bringing it. The bill settles the price of the meal. It does not settle what we owe each other as human beings, and no amount paid can purchase the right to humiliate.

Indian thought has held this view in its own language for a very long time. The Isha Upanishad says that the one who sees all beings in the Self, and the Self in all beings, no longer despises anyone. The Taittiriya Upanishad calls food itself Brahman. A tradition that regards food as sacred can hardly regard the hands that carry it to the table as unworthy of respect. The man with the bowl and the woman at the table shared the same life. The seats they occupied were different, and nothing more.

As an educationist, I have often wondered why our schools teach arithmetic, history and grammar with such seriousness and leave this entirely to chance. A child can complete twelve years of schooling without being taught how to speak to the person who brings the food, drives the bus or sweeps the corridor. Children learn it, if they learn it at all, by watching us. A child sitting at a restaurant table hears how a parent speaks to the waiter more clearly than any lesson delivered in a classroom. Empathy is taught at the table, in the car, at the gate, in the small tones of voice we use when we believe nothing important is happening.

It is easier to practise than it sounds. Look at the person who is serving us. Say thank you and mean it. Ask a name if the occasion allows. Pause for a breath before reacting to a mistake, and ask whether we would speak the same way to someone who had power over us. Remember a day when we sat in the other seat and were spoken to harshly, and recall what it did to the rest of that day. None of this takes money or time. Each one changes how the next person feels, and that effect travels the way anger does, from one person to the next.

Some people fear that this kind of gentleness is weakness, a loss of authority or standing. It is the opposite. Anyone can be gentle with those who have power over them. Gentleness toward someone who has none requires a steadier kind of strength, because nothing forces it and nobody will notice if it is missing.

I still think of the man with the tissue. He did not argue or explain that the drops were nothing. He apologised, wiped the leaf, and remained courteous to the end. He had every reason to be bitter, and he stayed gentle. I am not sure I could have done the same. That composure was a form of strength, and it taught me more about empathy than anything I have read.

After the payment, I asked whether there was another way I could give a tip to that particular man, since I had not carried any cash. Hesitantly, he showed me his QR code. I paid a small amount as a tip and walked out of the restaurant. I know that tiny sum could not erase the weight of the entire incident. All I wanted was a gentle smile on his face, and some ease for my own mind.

Perhaps, to treat with gentleness a person who serves us, who works to meet both ends, who stands before us with no means to answer, and who still meets our impatience with an apology, is one of the greatest signs of empathy.

A Few Drops of Raita: Why Empathy Toward the People Who Serve Us Matters Read More »

Whispers Between the Lines: The Gift of Today

Life has a quiet way of slipping past us while we are busy waiting for it to become something else.

How often have I caught myself thinking about yesterday-revisiting conversations, remembering choices I could have made differently, or wondering what might have happened if I had taken another path? And then there are thoughts about tomorrow: the work that needs to be completed, the plans that remain unfinished, the dreams that are still waiting, and the hope that someday life will become a little easier and more settled. Somewhere between yesterday and tomorrow, the present moment quietly passes us by.

I have often wondered why we find it so difficult to live in the moment we actually have. There have been days in my own life when I have been so occupied with what was yet to happen that I failed to notice what was already happening around me. A conversation with someone I loved would end while my mind was occupied with another responsibility. A beautiful evening would pass unnoticed because I was thinking about the following day. Even moments that deserved celebration sometimes became stepping stones to the next task rather than occasions to pause and feel grateful. Perhaps this is one of the quiet lessons life keeps trying to teach us: we do not have to wait for a perfect day to appreciate the day we have.

I remember how different life feels when we are truly present. A simple conversation with a friend can suddenly become meaningful when we put everything else aside and listen. Sitting with family over a meal can feel completely different when there is no hurry to leave. Even an ordinary cup of tea, enjoyed slowly in the quiet of the morning, can become a small moment of peace. These are not extraordinary events, yet they are often the moments that stay with us.

Sometimes, it takes a personal experience to understand the value of such moments. We may postpone a conversation thinking there will always be another opportunity. We may keep telling someone we love that we will call when we are less busy. We may imagine that there will always be another evening, another gathering, another chance to sit together. But life does not make such promises. That realisation has made me look differently at ordinary moments.

A child’s laughter is perhaps one of the best reminders of how to live in the present. Children do not need a grand occasion to be happy. A puddle becomes an adventure. A butterfly becomes something worth following. A sunset becomes something worth stopping to watch. They laugh completely and move from one moment to another without carrying the weight of yesterday or the anxiety of tomorrow.

Somewhere along the way, adulthood teaches us to hurry. We begin measuring our lives through achievements, deadlines, responsibilities, and comparisons. We start believing that happiness will arrive after the next promotion, after the next accomplishment, after the next journey, after everything is finally organised. Yet the finish line keeps moving. We achieve one thing and immediately begin thinking about the next.

Nature does not live that way. The flower does not hurry because another flower has bloomed before it. The river does not compare its journey with another river. The moon does not compete with the sun. Each exists in its own rhythm, quietly fulfilling its purpose. Perhaps we too need to learn that life is not a competition in which we must constantly prove that we are ahead.

Being present does not mean abandoning our responsibilities or refusing to prepare for tomorrow. Dreams need planning, and responsibilities cannot simply be ignored. But there is a difference between preparing for the future and sacrificing the present to it. We can plan tomorrow without forgetting today.

I have realised that some of the most precious moments in my life have not been the grand occasions at all. They have been the simple ones: a meaningful conversation, a friend’s unexpected message, laughter shared with family, a quiet morning, the satisfaction of completing something I once thought difficult or simply sitting peacefully and feeling grateful for the people who have remained a part of my journey. These moments may never appear in a biography. They may not be achievements that others notice. But they are the moments that give life its texture.

The present is also where healing begins. Yesterday may carry regrets, but today gives us the opportunity to make peace with them. Tomorrow may bring uncertainty, but today gives us the courage to take one step forward. We cannot rewrite what has already happened, nor can we completely control what is waiting ahead. But we can decide how we will meet this day.

Sometimes, living in the present means forgiving ourselves for what we could not change.

Perhaps this week, I want to remind myself and anyone reading these lines, to slow down. Look at the morning sky before beginning the day’s rush. Listen carefully when someone speaks to you. Call a friend simply because you remembered them. Sit with your family without reaching for your phone. Enjoy your tea while it is still warm. Read a few pages of a book. Take a walk without turning it into another task. Notice the breeze, the trees, the changing light, the familiar voices around you.

One day, we may look back and realise that the life we were constantly waiting for was already unfolding around us. The happiness we postponed, the conversations we delayed, the evenings we hurried through, and the ordinary days we considered unimportant were, in fact, our life.

That thought has made me more grateful for today.

We cannot hold yesterday, and we cannot borrow tomorrow. All we truly possess is this moment-the conversation happening now, the people beside us now, the breath we are taking now, and the opportunity to live this day with awareness.

Life is not measured only by milestones. It is also measured by the moments between them-the laughter, the silence, the affection, the forgiveness, the friendships, the unexpected kindness, and the quiet contentment that asks for nothing more than our attention.

Today will never come again exactly in the same way. So let us not be so busy preparing for tomorrow that we forget to live today. Let us not become so occupied with what is missing that we fail to appreciate what is already present. Let us give the people we love not merely our presence, but our attention. Let us allow ourselves to pause, breathe, notice, and be grateful.

Because perhaps the greatest gift life offers us is not a promise of a better tomorrow.

It is the opportunity to live this day fully.

Reflection of the Week

Yesterday has already become a memory. Tomorrow is still a possibility. But today is alive in our hands. Let us not miss the gift while waiting for something else.

Until next week, slow down, look around, and be present. You may discover that some of the moments you have been waiting for are already quietly happening in your life.

About the Author

Dr. Janatha Ramanathan is a poet, critic, translator, short story writer and columnist, and Associate Professor of English at Sree Ayyappa College for Women, Chunkankadai, Tamil Nadu. In two decades of teaching, she has published over eighty-five articles and presented ninety papers at national and international platforms, with particular scholarly focus on South African Literature.

She is Founder and Chief Editor of The Daffodils – An International Journal of Literature, Language and Criticism, and has edited seven anthologies of academic research and four poetry collections. Her own works, including her debut collection A Bundle of Joy, engage deeply with Indian, African American and Subaltern literatures.

Her honours include the Most Influential Women Award 2021 from the Writers Capital Foundation, Athens, and the Best Researcher Award from the University of Malaya, Malaysia.

Whispers Between the Lines: The Gift of Today Read More »

Psychopathology, Magical Thinking, and the Claims of Divine Identity

The Sovereign Mind: Psychopathology, Magical Thinking, and the Claims of Divine Identity

The persistent emergence of individuals claiming divine status, cosmic authority, or supernatural capabilities remains a striking phenomenon across human cultures. Throughout history, societies have wrestled with distinguishing between genuine spiritual awakening, charismatic leadership, and profound psychological disturbance. While religious traditions often frame these claims through theological concepts of avatarhood or divine selection, modern clinical psychology, psychiatry, and neurology analyze them as complex expressions of human cognition.
The unshakeable conviction that one is a deity, an incarnate prophet, or an omnipotent cosmic force rarely appears as an isolated thought. Instead, it represents an elaborate construction built at the intersection of neurobiological alteration, severe psychological trauma, defensive ego structures, and complex behavioral conditioning. Understanding these individuals requires a detailed examination of the mental processes that transform internal suffering into claims of divine power, as well as the role that obsessive-compulsive dynamics play in maintaining these rigid mental systems.

Part I: The Neurobiology of Grandiose and Religious Delusions

In clinical practice, an unshakeable belief in one’s own divinity or supernatural influence falls under the classification of a grandiose delusion or a religious delusion. These clinical presentations exist along a broad continuum. They range from acute, temporary stress responses triggered by extreme exhaustion or substance use to persistent neurodevelopmental and psychiatric conditions such as schizophrenia, schizoaffective disorder, and bipolar disorder during severe manic episodes.
                         THE ARCHITECTURE OF DIVINE CLAIMS
                         
          ┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
          │                    UNDERLYING VULNERABILITY                 │
          │     Dopaminergic Dysregulation & Limbic Hyper-Connectivity   │
          └──────────────────────────────┬──────────────────────────────┘
                                         │
                                         ▼
          ┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
          │                      PSYCHIC RUPTURE                        │
          │        Severe Trauma, Powerlessness, or Deep Loss           │
          └──────────────────────────────┬──────────────────────────────┘
                                         │
                                         ▼
          ┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
          │                     EGO RE-STRUCTURE                        │
          │       Inversion of Helplessness into Divine Control         │
          └──────────────────────────────┬──────────────────────────────┘
                                         │
                                         ▼
          ┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
          │                   BEHAVIORAL RIGIDITY                       │
          │   Magical Thinking, Compulsive Rituals, Social Validation   │
          └─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘

Dysregulation of Salience Networks

The human brain relies on complex neural circuits to evaluate incoming sensory data, monitor internal thought processes, assign appropriate weight to experiences, and maintain a stable sense of identity. When these neural pathways experience disruption, an individual’s perception of reality alters dramatically.
A central concept in understanding these states is the dysregulation of the salience network, primarily driven by altered dopamine signaling in the brain. Dopamine functions as a primary chemical signal for assigning emotional importance and meaning to both internal thoughts and external environmental events. Under normal circumstances, the brain filters out vast amounts of neutral information, allowing an individual to focus only on relevant cues.
When dopamine pathways become hyperactive, this filtering mechanism breaks down. The brain enters a state of heightened salience, wherein every perception feels charged with intense, personal significance. A passing glance from a stranger on the street, an unusual pattern of clouds, a specific sequence of numbers on a clock, or a sudden random thought is no longer processed as a mundane occurrence. Instead, the mind interprets it as an intentional, coded sign delivered specifically to them. As these perceived signs accumulate, the individual creates a cohesive narrative to explain why the universe seems to communicate with them directly, ultimately concluding that they possess a unique, divine status.

Impairments in Auditory and Self-Monitoring Networks

Healthy cognitive function depends on continuous, background self-monitoring. When an individual engages in internal speech or forms a thought, the brain sends a subtle signal that identifies the thought as self-generated.
In psychiatric conditions involving auditory hallucinations or passive phenomena, this internal tracking mechanism founders. When a thought occurs without being recognized as self-generated, the mind perceives it as an external voice or an intrusive transmission from an outside source. If these internal voices command the individual, offer constant commentary, or proclaim their special destiny, the person may arrive at a logical conclusion based on their altered perception: that they are receiving direct, unfiltered communication from God, or that they are an instrument through which a deity speaks.

Temporal Lobe and Limbic System Activation

The temporal lobes, along with limbic structures such as the amygdala and hippocampus, play a central role in processing emotional depth, memory, and the subjective experience of awe. Neurological research demonstrates that localized hyper-connectivity or electrical bursts within these regions can generate profound subjective states.
During these neurological events, individuals frequently report an sudden dissolution of personal boundaries, a feeling of overwhelming light, intense emotional warmth, and a conviction of absolute cosmic unity. While an individual in a balanced state might reflect on such a peak experience as a fleeting moment of awe, an individual with compromised cognitive defenses may interpret the physical sensation literally. Rather than recognizing the experience as a temporary neurological state, the mind concludes that the physical sense of boundless power confirms their actual identity as a divine entity.

Part II: Trauma, Disempowerment, and the Defensive Reconstruction of the Self

While neurobiological factors create the underlying vulnerability, psychological trauma, profound personal loss, or total social defeat often act as the immediate catalyst for these grand systems of belief.

The Dynamics of Ego Inversion

At its fundamental level, a delusion of divine identity frequently functions as an extreme psychological defense mechanism. When a person experiences unbearable powerlessness, physical abuse, deep humiliation, or total social failure, the mind faces potential emotional fragmentation. The pain of acknowledging one’s complete vulnerability can prove too heavy for the conscious self to sustain.
To prevent psychological collapse, the mind engages in an unconscious process of inversion:
  1. The Initial Rupture: The individual encounters an overwhelming situation marked by severe powerlessness, terror, or deep shame.
  2. Rejection of Reality: The conscious mind finds the painful reality unacceptable and seeks an immediate escape from the conviction of personal inadequacy.
  3. The Counter-Narrative: The ego constructs an opposing reality. It transforms the feeling of powerlessness into its direct opposite: absolute, unassailable power.
  4. Permanent Stabilization: The belief that one is a divine incarnation or an immortal figure acts as an impenetrable armor. If one is God, then no human being can inflict pain, no earthly authority can judge them, and no physical loss can diminish their ultimate value.

The Misinterpretation of Transcendental States

Spontaneous altered states of consciousness can occur naturally during periods of prolonged sensory deprivation, severe sleep disruption, intense physical stress, or deep meditative practices. During these states, the ordinary cognitive filters that maintain a rigid boundary between the self and the surrounding environment temporarily relax.
An individual who undergoes this dissolution of self-boundaries experiences a temporary feeling of merging with the universe. However, if this experience occurs in a mind burdened by unresolved trauma or severe emotional insecurity, a classic cognitive error occurs. The ego claims ownership of the universal experience. Instead of realizing that they experienced a moment of boundless connection, the person comes to believe that their individual ego commands that boundless power. The subjective experience of “all is one” transforms into the delusion that “I am the one.”

Part III: The Role of Obsessive-Compulsive Dynamics and Magical Thinking

A vital clinical observation in many individuals who claim spiritual authority or divine powers is the presence of symptoms associated with Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD). While public understanding of OCD often focuses on physical cleanliness or symmetry, the core structure of the condition centers on an overwhelming need for absolute certainty and total control over an unpredictable world.
                  THE EVOLUTION OF MAGICAL THINKING TO DELUSION
                  
┌──────────────────────────┐      ┌──────────────────────────┐      ┌──────────────────────────┐
│   UNBEARABLE ANXIETY     │ ───► │    MAGICAL THINKING      │ ───► │   RIGID COMPULSIONS      │
│ Deep dread of chaos,     │      │ Internal thoughts act    │      │ Repetitive routines      │
│ harm, or divine anger    │      │ directly on reality      │      │ to maintain balance      │
└──────────────────────────┘      └──────────────────────────┘      └──────────────────────────┘
                                                                                 │
                                                                                 ▼
┌──────────────────────────┐      ┌──────────────────────────┐      ┌──────────────────────────┐
│   DIVINE IDENTITY        │ ◄─── │  COSMIC REFRAMING        │ ◄─── │ PERCEIVED OMNIPOTENCE    │
│ Unshakeable conviction   │      │ Rituals reinterpreted as │      │ Belief that personal     │
│ of divine authority      │      │ unique spiritual duty    │      │ actions sustain reality  │
└──────────────────────────┘      └──────────────────────────┘      └──────────────────────────┘

The Mechanism of Magical Thinking

At the heart of obsessive-compulsive cognition lies the concept of magical thinking. This is the belief that one’s internal thoughts, specific spoken words, or precise physical movements have a direct, causal influence on external physical events, despite no logical connection between them.
For example, a person with OCD may experience an intrusive thought that a catastrophic event will occur unless they flip a light switch a set number of times or repeat a silent phrase. When magical thinking interacts with grandiose tendencies, it expands into a broader belief system:
  • Inflated Causality: The individual becomes convinced that their private mental routines, specific hand gestures, or internal intentions directly influence world events, natural weather patterns, or the health of people around them.
  • The Transition to Omnipotence: Over time, the heavy burden of feeling personally responsible for preventing bad events shifts into a feeling of ultimate power. The cognitive process evolves from a fearful obligation into a conviction of authority: “My mind holds direct power over physical reality, and therefore the maintenance of world balance depends entirely on my presence.”

Scrupulosity and the Reinterpretation of Compulsions

Scrupulosity represents a specific form of OCD characterized by persistent anxieties surrounding moral purity, religious sin, and the fear of incurring divine wrath. Individuals experiencing scrupulosity live in constant fear that their thoughts or actions are fundamentally flawed or offensive to higher powers.
To soothe this severe internal guilt, they develop exhausting, highly structured routines involving repetitive prayers, elaborate cleansing rituals, or precise physical postures. As these compulsions consume their daily lives, the individual experiences immense exhaustion.
To give meaning to this unending suffering, the mind reframes the experience. Instead of recognizing these repetitive actions as a manifestation of an anxiety disorder, the individual constructs an elevated narrative:
  • The distressing compulsions are reinterpreted as sacred trials assigned directly by God.
  • The exhausting mental burden is viewed as proof of their special spiritual status.
  • The individual arrives at the conviction that they have been selected to bear this unique burden because they are a prophet, an avatar, or a divine protector of humanity.

Part IV: Social Reinforcement and the Guru Dynamic

A personal delusion can remain a private experience, but when an individual asserting divine powers enters a social setting, a powerful interactive dynamic develops. When a person experiencing grandiose beliefs encounters people who are themselves seeking direction, emotional healing, or absolute certainty, a self-reinforcing loop takes shape.
┌────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│                   INDIVIDUAL ASSERTING DIVINE POWER                    │
│   Displays total absence of doubt, absolute authority, and conviction   │
└───────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────┘
                                    │
                                    ▼
┌────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│                          RECEPTIVE FOLLOWERS                           │
│   Seek structure, protection, and relief from personal uncertainty      │
└───────────────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────┘
                                    │
                                    ▼
┌────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│                       MUTUAL REINFORCEMENT LOOP                        │
│   Adoration confirms leader's delusion; leader offers security       │
│      Social isolation hardens belief into shared reality               │
└────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘

The Attraction to Absolute Certainty

Individuals in states of severe personal distress, loss, or existential confusion often seek external structure. When they encounter a leader who projects total freedom from self-doubt and claims to possess direct access to divine power, the message can exert a strong pull. The leader’s unshakeable certainty offers an immediate remedy for the follower’s internal ambiguity.

The Feedback Loop of Adoration

As followers offer devotion, financial support, and obedience, an external feedback loop confirms the internal delusion:
  1. External Confirmation: The devotion displayed by followers serves as physical proof to the leader that their divine claims are genuine. The leader thinks: “If I were not divine, these people would not bow before me.”
  2. Escalation of Claims: Encouraged by the surrounding praise, the leader’s claims grow more absolute, demanding greater levels of devotion and compliance from the group.
  3. Insulation from Critique: The group gradually isolates itself from outside perspectives. Critical feedback from family members, medical professionals, or society is labeled as spiritual opposition or ignorance. This social isolation seals off the leader’s delusion, transforming a severe psychological symptom into an entrenched social reality.

Comparative Analysis of Psychological Mechanisms

Psychological Mechanism Primary Neuro-Psychic Driver Core Cognitive Distortion Clinical and Behavioral Expression
Dysregulated Salience Dopaminergic hyperactivity Assigning profound personal meaning to neutral events Reading intentional divine messages in ordinary coincidences
Ego Inversion Severe trauma or profound loss Transforming vulnerability into absolute power Adopting a divine identity to shield against emotional pain
Limbic Activation Temporal lobe hyper-connectivity Equating intense emotional states with objective truth Interpreting feelings of awe as physical proof of godhood
Magical Thinking (OCD) High anxiety and need for control Believing thoughts directly alter physical events Performing rigid mental routines to control external reality
Scrupulosity Moral anxiety and deep guilt Reframing compulsive routines as sacred duties Viewing repetitive behaviors as a unique divine obligation

The conviction that one is a divine figure or possesses supernatural abilities is rarely a matter of simple vanity or intentional deceit. Instead, it represents a complex psychological and neurological structure constructed by a vulnerable mind attempting to navigate altered neurochemistry, intense internal anxiety, or deep emotional pain.
By examining these presentations through the combined lenses of neurobiology, trauma defense mechanisms, and obsessive-compulsive dynamics, we gain a clearer understanding of the human mind. The emergence of divine claims highlights the extreme lengths to which the human psyche will go to protect itself, impose order on internal chaos, and preserve a sense of ultimate meaning in an unpredictable world.

The Sovereign Mind: Psychopathology, Magical Thinking, and the Claims of Divine Identity Read More »

The Electric Vehicle Environmental Myth: What Happens Before and After the Charging Point?

The Electric Vehicle Environmental Myth: What Happens Before and After the Charging Point?

The electric vehicle has become one of the most powerful symbols of the modern environmental movement. The logic appears straightforward. A petrol or diesel vehicle burns fuel, produces exhaust gases and contributes to atmospheric pollution, whereas an electric vehicle has no tailpipe and therefore appears to offer a cleaner form of transportation. Governments encourage the transition, automobile manufacturers invest billions in electrification, and consumers are increasingly told that purchasing an electric vehicle represents a responsible environmental choice. There is considerable truth in this argument, but there is also a substantial amount of simplification. An electric vehicle does not eliminate the environmental cost of transportation. It changes the nature and location of that cost, and understanding that distinction is essential if the environmental claims surrounding electric mobility are to be examined honestly.

The first misconception arises from the phrase “zero-emission vehicle”. A battery-electric vehicle is a zero-tailpipe-emission vehicle, which means that it does not release exhaust gases while it is being driven. That is an important distinction because urban air quality benefits when combustion engines are removed from congested streets. It does not mean, however, that the vehicle itself was produced without emissions or that the electricity used to operate it was generated without emissions. The electricity has to be produced somewhere, the battery has to be manufactured, the minerals have to be extracted and processed, the vehicle has to be assembled, and all of these activities require energy and materials. The environmental assessment therefore has to begin before the vehicle reaches the showroom and continue until the vehicle and its battery reach the end of their useful lives.

The Battery Begins Its Life in a Mine

The battery is the most frequently overlooked component in the popular image of the electric vehicle. A conventional car certainly requires substantial quantities of steel, aluminium, copper, plastics, glass and other materials, but an electric vehicle adds a large electrochemical storage system whose manufacture depends upon an extensive international mineral supply chain. Lithium-ion batteries can involve lithium, graphite, nickel, cobalt, manganese, copper and other materials, depending on the particular chemistry.

The scale of this demand is already considerable. According to the International Energy Agency, global demand for batteries in the energy sector reached approximately 1 TWh in 2024, with electric-vehicle battery demand exceeding 950 GWh, an increase of approximately 25 percent in a single year. The IEA has reported that demand continued to grow strongly in 2025 as electric-vehicle sales expanded.

The consequences of this expansion are not confined to factories. Minerals have to be extracted from the earth, transported and refined before they become battery-grade materials. The IEA reports that demand for lithium rose by nearly 30 percent in 2024, while demand for nickel, cobalt, graphite and rare earth elements also increased substantially, with energy applications such as electric vehicles and battery storage accounting for much of the growth in several of these minerals. Mining can disturb land, consume water, generate waste and require large quantities of energy. The severity of these effects varies according to the mineral, extraction method, geographical location and environmental standards under which the operation is conducted, so it would be misleading to describe all battery mining as equally destructive. It would be equally misleading to pretend that the extraction has no environmental consequences simply because the final product is marketed as green technology.

Manufacturing Creates an Initial Carbon Burden

The environmental cost continues after the minerals have been extracted. They must be refined and transformed into materials that can be incorporated into battery cells, and those cells subsequently have to be assembled into modules and battery packs. Battery manufacturing is an energy-intensive industrial process, and the source of that energy has a direct influence on the resulting carbon footprint.

This produces an important difference between an electric vehicle and a conventional vehicle at the beginning of their respective lives. An EV can have higher manufacturing emissions because of its battery even though it can subsequently produce much lower emissions during operation. The International Council on Clean Transportation’s 2025 life-cycle assessment of passenger cars sold in the European Union estimated that battery-electric vehicles had approximately 40 percent higher production emissions than comparable internal-combustion vehicles, primarily because of battery production. The same study found that this initial disadvantage was offset after approximately 17,000 kilometres of use under the study’s European conditions.

This distinction is important because two statements that are frequently presented as contradictory are actually both capable of being true. An electric vehicle can require more emissions to manufacture than a comparable petrol vehicle while still producing substantially fewer emissions over its entire lifetime. The first statement describes the beginning of the vehicle’s life. The second describes the complete life cycle.

Electricity Does Not Come from the Charging Socket

The second major misconception concerns the electricity itself. An electric vehicle has no exhaust pipe, but the electricity stored in its battery has been generated somewhere. If that electricity comes predominantly from low-carbon sources such as solar, wind, hydroelectricity or nuclear power, the operational carbon footprint of the vehicle can be relatively low. If it comes predominantly from coal-fired generation, the climate advantage becomes smaller.

This is particularly relevant to India. The latest IEA data show that coal remained responsible for approximately 71 percent of India’s electricity generation in 2025, although that share has declined from approximately 74 percent in 2024 and 76 percent a decade earlier. At the same time, renewable generation continues to expand, meaning that India’s electricity system is gradually changing rather than remaining fixed.

The implication is not that an electric vehicle in India is simply a coal-powered vehicle. Such a statement would ignore India’s growing solar, wind and hydroelectric generation and would also ignore the expected decarbonisation of the electricity system. The implication is that the environmental performance of an EV cannot be separated from the electricity system that supplies it. An electric vehicle charged primarily from renewable electricity has a different life-cycle footprint from an otherwise identical vehicle charged from a grid dominated by coal.

The IEA’s global life-cycle assessment illustrates why the distinction matters. For a medium-sized battery-electric car sold in 2023, the agency estimated that lifetime emissions were approximately half those of an equivalent internal-combustion vehicle over roughly 200,000 kilometres under its stated-policies scenario. The advantage increases as electricity systems become cleaner.

Consequently, the criticism that “electric cars are powered by coal” is insufficient to establish that EVs are environmentally worse than petrol or diesel cars. At the same time, the assertion that an electric vehicle has no emissions is equally incomplete. The electricity source matters, and it matters considerably.

The Obsession with Range Creates Another Environmental Problem

The battery question becomes even more significant when vehicle size is considered. The automobile industry has increasingly marketed long driving ranges as a major selling point. Consumers naturally appreciate the convenience of travelling several hundred kilometres without recharging, but greater range usually requires greater battery capacity. A larger battery requires more materials and more energy to manufacture, and the additional weight has consequences throughout the vehicle’s life.

This creates a peculiar situation in which an enormous electric SUV can be marketed as an environmentally responsible product simply because it has an electric motor. The absence of a combustion engine does not make the vehicle immaterial. A large vehicle still requires large quantities of steel, aluminium, glass, plastics, rubber and battery materials, and it still consumes energy to move its mass.

The environmental difference between a small electric hatchback and a large electric SUV can therefore be substantial. The question should not merely be whether the vehicle is electric. It should include how much material was required to produce it, how large its battery is, how much electricity it consumes and how long it remains in service.

This is one reason why the environmental discussion becomes distorted when electrification is treated as the entire solution. Replacing a large petrol vehicle with a similarly large electric vehicle can reduce lifetime greenhouse-gas emissions, but it does not eliminate the resource requirements associated with private automobile ownership.

The Exhaust Pipe Disappears, but Particulate Pollution Does Not

There is another important environmental distinction. Electric vehicles eliminate tailpipe emissions, and this provides a significant air-quality advantage, particularly in densely populated urban areas. However, vehicles produce particulate matter through other mechanisms.

Tyres wear against road surfaces. Roads themselves undergo abrasion. Brake components generate particulate matter, although regenerative braking in electric vehicles can substantially reduce conventional brake wear. Dust deposited on roads can also be resuspended by passing vehicles.

Vehicle weight becomes important in this context. Electric vehicles can be heavier than comparable combustion vehicles because of their battery packs, particularly when they are designed for long driving ranges. An OECD analysis of non-exhaust particulate emissions examined this relationship and found that longer-range battery-electric vehicles can be substantially heavier than comparable internal-combustion vehicles. Its modelling included examples in which long-range BEVs were 34 to 41 percent heavier than corresponding internal-combustion vehicles, depending on vehicle class.

This does not mean that electric vehicles necessarily produce more particulate pollution overall. The reduction in brake wear and elimination of exhaust emissions remain important advantages. It means that the phrase “zero-emission vehicle” should not be interpreted as “zero particulate pollution”. The environmental effects of tyres, roads and vehicle mass remain relevant regardless of the propulsion system.

What Happens to the Battery at the End?

The battery introduces another question that will become increasingly important as the first large generation of modern EV batteries reaches the end of its automotive service life. A battery that is no longer suitable for a vehicle does not necessarily become useless. Depending on its condition, it may be capable of a second life in stationary energy storage before eventually being recycled.

Battery recycling can recover valuable materials and reduce dependence on virgin mineral extraction. The development of effective recycling systems is therefore central to the long-term environmental performance of electric mobility. At present, however, the industry is still constructing the infrastructure necessary to deal with the enormous number of batteries that will eventually reach retirement as the global EV fleet expands.

This is another reason why the environmental assessment of electric vehicles cannot stop at the point of sale. The true environmental footprint extends from mineral extraction through manufacturing and operation to reuse and recycling. A battery that is manufactured with high emissions, used for a relatively short period and poorly managed at the end of its life presents a different environmental calculation from one that remains in service for many years and eventually enters an efficient recycling system.

The Real Problem Is the Assumption That Changing the Powertrain Solves Everything

There is a broader issue that is often lost in the debate between petrol and electric vehicles. The environmental burden of transportation does not arise solely from the fuel used by a vehicle. It also arises from the production of vehicles, the extraction of materials, the construction and maintenance of roads, the creation of parking infrastructure and the enormous quantity of resources required to maintain a global system of private automobile ownership.

An electric vehicle changes the propulsion technology without eliminating these requirements. This is why a small, efficient vehicle can have a substantially different environmental footprint from a large vehicle, even when both use electric propulsion. It is also why public transportation, walking and cycling can provide environmental benefits that cannot be obtained merely by replacing one private automobile with another.

The IEA illustrates the efficiency advantage of electrification at the system level. Global EVs consumed approximately 180 TWh of electricity in 2024, yet the agency estimates that EV adoption can substantially reduce energy demand relative to conventional road transport because electric drivetrains are considerably more efficient. The IEA projects EV electricity consumption to reach approximately 780 TWh by 2030 under its stated-policies scenario, while total road-transport energy demand rises by only about 5 percent despite almost 20 percent growth in vehicle kilometres travelled.

The environmental challenge, therefore, is not simply that electric vehicles consume electricity. They consume electricity far more efficiently than combustion engines consume fuel. The challenge is ensuring that the electricity, batteries and materials required for this transition are produced with progressively lower environmental costs.

So, Is the Electric Vehicle Actually Greener?

The evidence does not support the claim that electric vehicles are an environmental fraud. Nor does it support the simplistic idea that an electric vehicle is automatically clean simply because it has no exhaust pipe.

The strongest available life-cycle assessments generally find that battery-electric cars have lower greenhouse-gas emissions than comparable petrol or diesel vehicles over their complete lifetimes. The ICCT’s 2025 European assessment estimated that battery-electric cars sold in the European Union produce 73 percent lower life-cycle greenhouse-gas emissions than comparable gasoline vehicles, even after including vehicle and battery production, electricity production, maintenance and recycling. The study also found that the initial manufacturing emissions of EVs were recovered after approximately 17,000 kilometres under its assumptions.

The global picture is less uniform because electricity systems differ considerably between countries. The IEA’s global assessment nevertheless reaches the same broad conclusion, estimating that a medium-sized battery-electric car sold in 2023 produces roughly half the lifetime emissions of an equivalent internal-combustion vehicle over approximately 200,000 kilometres.

These findings matter because they prevent one environmental myth from being replaced by another. The existence of mining impacts, battery manufacturing emissions and coal-fired electricity does not prove that EVs are worse than conventional cars. The absence of tailpipe emissions does not prove that EVs are environmentally harmless. The truth lies in the life-cycle calculation.

India’s Other Motive: Energy Security

India’s transition towards electric mobility also needs to be understood within the broader context of national energy security. The environmental argument is prominent in public policy, but reducing dependence on imported petroleum is an equally significant strategic consideration. India imports the overwhelming majority of the crude oil it consumes, leaving transportation particularly exposed to international oil prices, geopolitical tensions, supply disruptions and movements in the value of the rupee. Every petrol and diesel vehicle therefore represents continuing demand for a commodity whose supply and price are substantially influenced outside India’s borders. An electric vehicle changes this equation by shifting a significant portion of transportation energy demand towards electricity, which can increasingly be generated from domestic sources such as solar, wind and hydroelectric power.

Government incentives for electric vehicles should consequently not be understood as measures motivated exclusively by climate policy. India’s electric-mobility programmes also serve industrial, technological and strategic objectives, including reducing petroleum consumption, developing domestic manufacturing capabilities and improving energy security. The environmental benefits are real, but they exist alongside these wider national interests.

There is also a long-term economic question that deserves public discussion. Electricity may currently appear considerably cheaper for transportation than petrol or diesel, particularly when an EV is charged at home, but today’s pricing structure cannot necessarily be assumed to remain unchanged as electric vehicles become widespread. Petrol and diesel generate substantial government revenue through excise duties, state taxes and other levies. If petroleum consumption declines substantially, governments will eventually face the fiscal question of replacing at least part of that revenue. At the same time, mass electrification will require additional investment in generation, transmission, distribution and charging infrastructure. These pressures could eventually result in changes to electricity tariffs, taxation, road-user charges or other mechanisms for recovering public revenue.

There is presently no sufficient evidence to state that the government is deliberately concealing future electricity-price increases until electric vehicles become common. Such an assertion would go beyond what can be established. It is nevertheless reasonable to recognise that the economics of transportation can change when the underlying energy system changes. Consumers should therefore distinguish between the current cost advantage of electric mobility and the long-term cost of operating an increasingly electrified transportation system. The price of electricity, like the price of petroleum, is ultimately shaped by production costs, infrastructure, taxation, regulation and government policy.

The Environmental Question We Should Really Be Asking

The electric vehicle should therefore be understood as part of a wider transformation of transportation rather than as an inherently clean object. Its environmental advantage comes primarily from the much greater efficiency of electric propulsion and from the possibility of progressively supplying that propulsion with lower-carbon electricity. The advantage is substantial in many life-cycle assessments, but it does not erase the environmental costs associated with mineral extraction, battery manufacturing, electricity generation, vehicle production, road use and end-of-life processing.

The meaningful environmental question is consequently not whether an electric vehicle is “green” and a petrol vehicle is “dirty”. Such descriptions reduce a complex life-cycle calculation to the technology displayed on the vehicle’s badge. The relevant question is how much environmental damage is associated with producing, powering, operating and ultimately disposing of each vehicle over its useful life. That calculation must account for the battery, the electricity source, the size and weight of the vehicle, the distance it travels, the longevity of its components and the effectiveness of recycling.

The electric vehicle can therefore play an important role in reducing the environmental burden of transportation, but the transition should not be treated as the end of the environmental discussion. It is a change in the structure of energy consumption, material extraction and transportation economics. In India’s case, it is also a strategic attempt to reduce dependence on imported petroleum and increase the role of domestic energy resources. The environmental gains are significant, but they exist within a much larger economic and geopolitical transformation.

The charging socket is only one point in that system. The real environmental story begins with the extraction of minerals, continues through manufacturing and electricity generation, follows the vehicle throughout its useful life and ends with the treatment of its battery and other components. Only by examining that entire chain can the environmental consequences of electric mobility be understood without either exaggerating its benefits or dismissing them. The electric vehicle is not the environmental miracle that its marketing sometimes suggests, but neither is it the environmental failure that its critics sometimes claim. Its actual value can only be understood through the complete life-cycle of the vehicle, the energy system that powers it and the economic and strategic system that supports its adoption.

_________________________________________________________

In Short: Electric vehicles are not environmentally harmless simply because they produce no tailpipe emissions. Their environmental footprint begins with the extraction and processing of battery minerals, continues through energy-intensive manufacturing and electricity generation, and extends to tyre and road pollution, battery degradation and eventual recycling. At the same time, life-cycle studies show that battery-electric vehicles generally produce substantially lower greenhouse-gas emissions than comparable petrol and diesel vehicles over their full operating lives, particularly as electricity generation becomes cleaner. The real issue, therefore, is not whether electric vehicles are completely green or completely harmful, but how their total environmental cost compares with the alternatives. In India, the transition also has a strategic dimension because replacing petroleum with electricity can reduce dependence on imported crude oil and strengthen energy security. The electric vehicle is consequently neither the environmental miracle it is sometimes portrayed as nor the environmental failure its critics sometimes suggest. Its actual impact can only be understood by examining the entire chain from mineral extraction to manufacturing, electricity generation, use and eventual recycling.

The Electric Vehicle Environmental Myth: What Happens Before and After the Charging Point? Read More »

The Taboo Behind the “Smart City” Called Kakinada

When I got down in Kakinada in the early morning hours, I was expecting a rather difficult climate. Someone accustomed to the weather of a well-planned city like Mysuru rarely adjusts easily to most other Indian towns. Yet the heat and the air were gentler than I had anticipated. Perhaps a few years of living near Kerala’s coast had prepared me better than I realised. What I was not prepared for came later, as I walked towards the apartment where I was staying. I had to close my nostrils. There was no gradual build-up to it, no faint odour growing stronger with every step. It was simply there, all at once, the way a wall is there before you have decided to stop walking.

I did not think much of it that first morning. It was a new city, an unfamiliar lane, and perhaps an isolated problem. It was only a few days later, during an evening walk near the old Rangaraya Medical College with Dr Chandrashekhar, that the possibility of it being an isolated problem disappeared. A channel ran along the hospital boundary wall, carrying the same smell I had encountered on my first morning. Dr Chandrashekhar mentioned, almost without emphasis, that it had been running in much the same condition for as long as he could remember from his days as a student there. It was not a bad week or a bad season. It appeared to have become a permanent feature of the landscape, much like the old building itself.

That was enough to make me look beyond the particular lane and examine the administrative record behind what I was seeing. What emerged was a striking difference between the city described in official documents and the city experienced at street level.

What the Records Say

On paper, Kakinada Municipal Corporation presents a considerably different picture. The Andhra Pradesh State Portal has credited it with “exemplary waste management practices”, while the corporation has received national recognition under the Swachh Bharat Mission. Kakinada has also been part of the Government of India’s Smart Cities Mission for more than a decade. Initiatives such as “Return Gift” and “Legacy Waste Management” have been undertaken and publicly presented as evidence of the city’s continuing efforts towards urban improvement.

None of these claims is imaginary. The programmes exist, the recognitions exist and the expenditure associated with them can be traced through government records. The difficulty begins when that official picture is placed alongside the physical condition of parts of the city. A city may receive recognition for particular programmes and still have fundamental deficiencies in other areas of civic infrastructure. The question, therefore, is not whether Kakinada has achieved anything. It clearly has. The question is whether those achievements correspond to the conditions experienced by all sections of its population.

The Drainage Question

In several pockets of Kakinada, drainage channels function as open sewers, carrying wastewater along roads and residential settlements. In some places, families live only a few feet from them. The problem is particularly difficult to reconcile with the city’s Smart City status because Kakinada still does not have a functioning underground drainage system serving the city as a whole. More than a decade after its inclusion in the Smart Cities Mission, residents in substantial parts of the city continue to depend upon open drains that were designed primarily for storm-water disposal but have come to carry domestic wastewater as well.

The problem is therefore larger than the smell that first drew my attention to it. An open drain running beside a road may be dismissed as an ordinary feature of an Indian town, but the persistence of such a system in a city that has spent years within a national urban-modernisation programme raises a legitimate question about priorities, implementation and accountability. If underground drainage has long been recognised as necessary, why has the city continued to function without it for so many years?

When Infrastructure Becomes a Health Risk

The consequences of this deficit fall most heavily on the people who live closest to these channels. In several areas, low-income families live beside open drains, sometimes with infants and young children only a few feet from wastewater. Stagnant water and accumulated waste create conditions favourable to mosquito breeding and increase exposure to vector-borne diseases. The risks become particularly serious when drainage channels overflow during periods of heavy rainfall and contaminated water enters residential surroundings.

There is another vulnerability that receives less attention because it is not immediately visible. Where drinking-water pipelines run close to contaminated drainage channels, leakage or damage to either system can create the possibility of contamination. Municipal assessments have themselves identified the need to examine drinking-water pipelines in vulnerable areas. This is not a reason to predict a particular epidemic, but it is sufficient reason to regard the existing arrangement as a public-health concern requiring systematic inspection, monitoring and corrective action.

The people most exposed to these conditions are also often those with the least capacity to change them. A family living beside an open drain cannot simply move to another neighbourhood because the municipal infrastructure has failed. For a child growing up there, the drain is not an occasional civic inconvenience. It is part of the environment in which childhood takes place.

A Pattern Beyond the Drains

The drainage problem does not appear in isolation. Other aspects of Kakinada’s civic infrastructure reveal a similar distance between stated policy and conditions visible on the ground.

Despite years of sanitation campaigns, garbage remains visible along several suburban roads and thoroughfares. Where waste collection and decentralised processing do not function consistently, roadside accumulation and open burning become recurring problems. Irrigation canals that once formed an important part of the region’s agricultural landscape have, in stretches, become receptacles for solid waste and other pollutants. Traffic, damaged roads, construction activity and dust add another layer to the environmental burden.

Each of these problems can be assigned to a different department and explained as a local deficiency. Considered together, however, they raise a broader question about the way urban development is planned and measured. A city can produce successful projects, receive awards and report measurable improvements while significant parts of its population continue to live with infrastructure that should have disappeared decades ago.

This is where the idea of a Smart City becomes more complicated than a designation or a collection of projects. The quality of a city is ultimately experienced through its ordinary infrastructure: the water that reaches a household, the drainage that carries away its wastewater, the waste collected from its street, the air a child breathes and the roads people use every day.

Where Did the Investment Go?

The state’s recent approach to the Centre for approximately ₹200 crore under the Urban Infrastructure Development Fund for the construction of an underground drainage system in Kakinada makes the question more immediate. If approved and implemented, the funding could finally address one of the city’s most persistent infrastructure deficits. Yet the proposal inevitably raises another question: after more than a decade of Smart Cities Mission activity, alongside state municipal funding and sanitation programmes, why does Kakinada still require a fresh major intervention for infrastructure as fundamental as an underground drainage network?

That question is not, by itself, an allegation of financial wrongdoing. Establishing such a conclusion would require a detailed examination of financial and administrative records. But those records should be available for public scrutiny. How much has been sanctioned for Kakinada’s urban infrastructure during the past decade? How much has actually been released and spent? Which projects were approved, which were completed and which remain incomplete? What were their original estimates and revised costs? Which agencies were responsible for implementation and supervision? What explains the gap between projects announced and infrastructure actually delivered?

These are not unreasonable questions to ask of public institutions. They become particularly important when the physical condition of a city appears so different from the impression created by its official achievements. The answers should come from records rather than speculation, and responsibility should be established through those records rather than through political accusation.

What Accountability Requires

An independent sanitation and infrastructure audit would be an appropriate starting point. It should cover the city’s suburban and low-income settlements as well as the areas that receive greater visibility in official assessments, and it should be conducted independently of the municipal machinery whose performance is being examined. Its findings should be made publicly accessible, including the condition of drainage networks, waste-management systems, water pipelines and canal infrastructure.

The proposed underground drainage project should then have a transparent implementation schedule, with defined areas of coverage, expenditure, timelines and institutional responsibility. Progress should be measured not merely by administrative expenditure or project announcements but by the actual number of households connected to a functioning system.

The families already living along open drainage channels also cannot be treated as an incidental part of the infrastructure problem. Where rehabilitation becomes necessary, it should provide secure housing, sanitation, water supply and access to essential civic services rather than simply relocating people from one inadequate environment to another.

None of these demands is extraordinary. They are basic requirements of a city that wishes to describe itself as modern, sustainable and liveable. The issue is ultimately one of closing the distance between what has been promised, what has been reported and what residents actually experience.

The City Beyond the Smart City Tag

I am writing this from my balcony in Mysuru, days after returning from Kakinada, fresh from a nebulisation session that I now need each evening. Somewhere amid the smoke, dust and open drains of Kakinada, I developed a respiratory infection severe enough to require treatment. I cannot establish from my experience alone what caused it, and I do not intend to. My experience is simply the reason the environmental conditions I witnessed no longer remain an abstract matter for me. I was a visitor. I left. For many of the families I saw living beside those drains, particularly the children growing up there, these conditions are not something encountered during a short stay and left behind with the next train. They are part of everyday life.

Looking at a clearer sky from my balcony, I keep returning to the question of what a Smart City should actually mean. It cannot mean only the projects that appear in presentations, the awards displayed in offices or the statistics recorded in reports. A city is experienced at street level, beside the drains, along the roads, near the canals and inside the homes of the people who live there. A child’s access to clean air, clean water and basic sanitation should not depend on which municipal corporation happens to govern the street on which that child was born.

I hope this reaches the desks for which it is intended. I hope it is read as a record of what I saw, followed by questions that the responsible institutions can answer through facts and records. The purpose is not to condemn Kakinada. It is to ask whether the city that exists on paper is the same city in which its people are actually living.

The Taboo Behind the “Smart City” Called Kakinada Read More »

History of Rangaraya Medical College - an exclusive article

Rangaraya Medical College: A Legacy Carved in Community

Beyond the bustle of Kakinada’s evening traffic, I came upon a building that seemed to hold its ground with a kind of authority, old, weathered by decades, yet unmistakably dignified against the newer structures crowding the road around it. I was walking with Dr. Chandrashekhar, an MD student at the college, who had offered to show me around the campus. Until that walk, I had no real sense of the history sitting inside those walls, only a vague awareness that the institution had been there for a long time, the way most of us know a landmark exists without ever asking how it came to be.

It was already evening, well past the hours one would expect any real activity, and yet a number of people stood outside the hospital gates in scattered groups, waiting, talking quietly among themselves, in no apparent hurry to be anywhere else. Something about that stillness, an old building holding a crowd of strangers even after its working hours had ended, stayed with me long enough that I went looking into its history once I was back home, curious to understand what this place had meant to the region before it meant anything to me.

Beginning that search, I assumed, the way most people would, that its history followed the predictable path of India’s legacy institutions, a wealthy king handing over a parcel of land, a government cutting a ribbon, or a single wealthy physician erecting a monument to his own name. What I found instead was something far more complex and worth telling properly, a story that deserves to be carried forward to the generations of students and patients who will walk these same corridors long after I have.

The genesis of RMC is an intricate mosaic of post-independence ambition, an unprecedented linguistic compromise in naming, an orphanage that moonlighted as a medical campus, and an intellectual lineage that stretches all the way to Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose’s inner circle. To uncover the founding of Rangaraya Medical College is to explore a masterclass in community-led, private-sector resourcefulness that transformed coastal Andhra Pradesh for good.

The Problem of the Missing Physicians

To understand why RMC was built, one must look at the geography of the late 1950s. The newly carved state of Andhra Pradesh was grappling with a massive deficit of healthcare professionals. While elite medical colleges existed in cities like Visakhapatnam and Guntur, the fertile, densely populated Godavari districts lacked a dedicated medical training ground.

The idea to plug this gap did not originate in a bureaucratic office in New Delhi or Hyderabad. It was conceived by local visionaries who realised that if they waited for the state to build a medical college, a generation of students would lose out.

The initial spark came in 1955 from Dr. Mallavarapu Venkata Krishna Rao, a former Education Minister in the cabinet of Chakravarti Rajagopalachari during the era of the composite Madras State. Dr. Krishna Rao had the political foresight to know what it took to build an institution, but he needed structural and military-grade execution. He found his partner in Colonel Dr. Datla Satyanarayana Raju, known as Dr. D.S. Raju, a medical figure who had served as the personal doctor to Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose during the Indian National Army trials and later became the Deputy Minister of Defence and Health under Jawaharlal Nehru.

Together, these two men decided that if the government could not immediately fund a public medical college in Kakinada, they would rally the public to build a private one.

April 2, 1958: The Historic Meeting at Pithapuram Road

The dream officially shifted from concept to reality on April 2, 1958. A meeting was convened in Kakinada at the residence of a prominent local citizen, Dr. Lakkaraju Subbarao. The gathering included Sri Neelam Sanjiva Reddy, then the Chief Minister of Andhra Pradesh.

The organisers faced a real hurdle. They had no land and no buildings to house a medical college, an enterprise that requires extensive laboratory and classroom space.

Stepping into this gap was the Maharajah of Pithapuram. In an act of philanthropy, he gave his consent to hand over an orphanage building complex he was running on Pithapuram Road. A space originally built to shelter and care for vulnerable children became the incubator for the region’s future doctors.

To formalise the community support gathering around them, the founders registered the Kakinada Medical Education Society on April 16, 1958. Its mandate was clear and ambitious in equal measure, open a fully functioning private medical college by July of that same year.

The Name: A Portrait of Gratitude

Perhaps the most striking element of RMC’s history is its name. In the mid-20th century, if a private citizen funded a college, the institution typically bore their exact name. RMC broke that convention through a gesture of gratitude from the Kakinada Medical Education Society.

As the society scrambled for seed capital, it received financial support from regional families, including Sri P.S. Raju, the Zamindar of Goteru. The larger breakthrough came from an industrialist from Tanuku, Sri Mullapudi Harischandra Prasad, representing the Sri Mullapudi Venkata Rayudu Memorial Educational Trust, who donated five lakh rupees, an extraordinary sum at the time.

Rather than allow the college to be named after him, Prasad deflected the honour. In response, the society crafted a portmanteau name that honoured Prasad’s own family lineage, drawing “Ranga” from his late brother-in-law, Sri Pendyala Sriramachandra Venkata Krishna Rangarao, the Zamindar of Dommeru, and “Raya” from his grandfather, Sri Mullapudi Venkatarayudu.

By fusing the memory of the brother-in-law and the grandfather, the society named the institution Rangaraya Medical College, a rare instance in Indian academic history of a college named not after the person who wrote the cheque, but as a multi-generational tribute to a donor’s family roots.

Overcoming the Lack of a Hospital

While the orphanage building was modified to host classrooms, anatomy halls, and basic laboratories, a medical college is functionally incomplete without a teaching hospital of real capacity. Building one from scratch would have taken years the society did not have.

The founders turned to the existing District Headquarters Hospital in Kakinada, a facility with its own history rooted in British colonial-era public health infrastructure. On October 14, 1959, after negotiation with the state, the Government of Andhra Pradesh officially notified the Kakinada District Headquarters Hospital as the formal teaching hospital attached to Rangaraya Medical College, bridging a privately funded college with a publicly managed clinical space, and giving students access to a wide and varied patient base from the outset.

The Haldane Connection

As RMC found its footing through the 1960s, it began attracting attention from unexpected quarters. Among the more remarkable chapters in its history involves the British evolutionary biologist and geneticist J.B.S. Haldane, a polymath who renounced his British citizenship to become an Indian citizen and spent his final years working in the country.

Haldane developed a real respect for the grassroots medical movement taking shape in Kakinada. Before his passing in late 1964, he made his final request known, donating his body to the Pathology Department of Rangaraya Medical College for research and medical education. Haldane, who had famously written a poem on his own terminal illness, treating even his mortality as a final teaching tool, gave a regional medical college in coastal Andhra a striking form of validation, the mortal remains of one of the twentieth century’s most significant scientific minds.

The Shift to a State Institution

By the late 1970s, the financial burden of running a leading medical institution on private donations and subsidised fees had become unsustainable for the Kakinada Medical Education Society. To preserve the quality of education and allow the hospital infrastructure to scale with a growing population, the Government of Andhra Pradesh stepped in. In 1981, the state officially took over RMC, completing its transition from a private, society-run experiment into a premier government medical college.

A Legacy Carved in Community

Great institutions are rarely the work of a single force, and Rangaraya Medical College makes that case as clearly as any I have come across. It exists because an INA-connected physician, a former minister, a local landlord, an industrialist, and a Maharajah sat together in a living room on a spring afternoon and decided that the youth of the Godavari districts deserved better than what they had. The name on its façade does not represent a single ego. It represents a community’s way of saying thank you to a donor who asked for nothing in return, a piece of Kakinada’s own golden age of philanthropy, still standing, still treating patients, decades after the men who built it have passed on.

Walking out through those same gates that evening, I carried all of this history with me into the city outside. While returning, the streets of Kakinada were well lit. Beside the smell of the open drainage, people were already preparing to go to bed. I do not know how they manage to fall asleep so easily amid it all. Perhaps the chaos has simply become part of their life, absorbed so completely into the rhythm of the place that it no longer registers as chaos at all, only as home.

__________________________________________________

In short: A quiet, weathered building near Kakinada’s evening traffic and a crowd of people waiting outside its gates after hours sent the author looking into the history of Rangaraya Medical College. What emerged was a remarkable story of post-independence community effort: an INA veteran physician, a former minister, a Maharajah who donated an orphanage building, and an industrialist who refused to have the college named after himself, choosing instead to honor his late brother-in-law and grandfather through its name. The piece traces the college’s journey from a privately funded 1958 experiment to a state-run institution, including its unlikely connection to British scientist J.B.S. Haldane, who donated his body to its Pathology Department. It stands as a record meant to carry this history forward for generations of students and patients still to come.

Rangaraya Medical College: A Legacy Carved in Community Read More »

The Last Meeting Theory

As the ticket checker came to me and reconfirmed my name, I noticed a young man watching me from the berth across. Once the checker moved on, I let my face fall back into one of the books I had carried along for the long journey. I continued reading, though I could still feel him looking.

“Are you an author, sir?” he asked, after a while, moving closer to sit beside me. “I have seen the names of some of your books, and I went through your social media too.” Being recognised is a good thing, mostly, but the moment one starts placing popularity above peace, it turns into something heavier to carry. Whenever I travel, I choose the plainest clothes I own, since there is rarely anyone on these journeys I need to convince of anything.

I am still not entirely sure what made him open up the way he did, his life, his plans, and eventually, the concerns he had clearly been carrying somewhere deep for a long time. He spoke of a career he had chosen more out of family expectation than desire, a marriage he was still learning how to inhabit, and a restlessness he could not name even to himself. As I answered each thing he asked, I watched his eyes widen slightly, again and again. They were, in truth, questions offered back to him in a different shape, the kind that let a person reach their own answer rather than borrow someone else’s. I have found, over many years of these conversations, that most people already carry the answer they are looking for. What they lack is someone willing to sit across from them long enough for that answer to surface on its own.

A few hours later, his wife appeared and reminded him that his station was approaching. He rose slowly, began gathering his luggage, and as the train pulled in, he said goodbye and walked toward the door. It was only then that I noticed something unusual. We had never exchanged phone numbers. I had not even asked his name. He had not asked mine either.

This is not how these journeys usually end for me. If I were to go through the contacts saved on my phone, a great many of them would be people I first met exactly this way, on a train, mid conversation, somewhere between one station and another. Some of those meetings happened more than twenty five years ago, and the people from them are still close friends today, a few of them closer than that. I still remember the names of stations where such friendships began, the particular light coming through a train window, the small kindnesses exchanged over shared food, the addresses written by hand on torn pieces of paper before either of us owned a mobile phone. But this time, nothing. No name, no number, no promise to stay in touch. It was only afterward that a philosophy I had recently come across returned to me, one I had read but never truly felt settle into me until that moment. I have heard it called the Last Meeting Theory.

The theory holds a difficult truth. We never encounter the same thing twice, not even moments apart. Think of a river. I look at the water and say, this is the Ganga, or this is the Kaveri, and by the time the sentence has left my mouth, the water I named has already moved on, replaced by water that has never touched that stretch of riverbed before. The name stays. The river, in the only sense that actually matters, does not. This is not a poetic exaggeration. It is what a river actually is, a name we give to something that is never the same thing twice, moving continuously out from under the very word we use to hold it still. A philosopher in ancient Greece once said something close to this, that no one steps into the same river twice, since new waters are always flowing toward him. Long before that, our own sages spoke of anicca, the truth that nothing holds its form for even one full breath, that permanence itself is the illusion, not the exception.

Everything we think we return to carries this same betrayal. A flower noticed on a morning walk, admired in passing, may not exist by the time the same path is walked again, the plant itself gone, the ground beneath it changed, nothing left to mark where it once stood. Even a photograph, which we imagine holds a moment still, only holds the light that fell on a face that no longer exists in that exact arrangement, since the person in it has aged, however slightly, in every second since the shutter closed. We rarely think of any of this as loss, because we were never asked to say goodbye to it. It simply was, and then, at some point we did not witness, it was not.

Apply this to a person, and something in the chest tightens, the way it does with any truth we would rather not have named so plainly. Every person we meet, we meet exactly once, in the fullest sense of that word. The version of them sitting across from us on a particular afternoon, in a particular mood, carrying a particular set of concerns they may never carry again in that combination, will not exist in that form the next time we see them, if there is a next time at all. We meet people again, certainly, the same name, the same face, often the same affection. But we never meet the same meeting twice. Every conversation, however ordinary it feels, carries the possibility that it is the only one of its kind we will ever have with that person, whether or not we ever see them again in body.

This truth does not confine itself to strangers on trains. It lives inside the people we see every day, the ones we assume, wrongly, will always be available to us in exactly the shape we left them. A parent answering the phone this evening is not the same parent who answered it a year ago, a little more tired now, a little more given to repeating themselves, a year closer to an ending none of us like to name aloud. A child running through the house at this particular age, with this particular laugh and these particular questions about the world, will be gone within months, replaced by an older child who has already forgotten the exact way they once said certain words. We assume familiarity protects us from this, that because we will see these people again tomorrow, today’s version of them does not matter as urgently as a stranger glimpsed once on a journey. The truth runs the other way. It is precisely because we assume endless further meetings with the people closest to us that we so rarely give any single one of those meetings our full attention, and it is precisely the stranger, met once and never again, who sometimes receives the fuller version of our presence, simply because we knew, without needing a theory to tell us, that this was all the time we would ever have.

I did not truly understand this until that afternoon on the train, watching a stranger walk toward a door, realising only as it closed behind him that I would very likely never see him again, not because life had conspired to keep us apart, but because neither of us had done the ordinary thing people do to ensure otherwise. There was no tragedy in it. There was, suddenly, a window into something true of every meeting, whether we notice it or not, one that most of us pass through a thousand times in a lifetime without ever pausing long enough to look through it properly.

As the train continued its journey, I began watching the people who boarded and got off at each stop differently. I smiled at them. I let whatever love I could offer in a glance actually reach them, because I would very likely never see any of them again in this lifetime.

The train stopped at the station early in the morning. A few people were still asleep on the benches along the platform. Others were already walking briskly toward the exit. As I walked toward the gate myself, I tried to hold on to their faces a moment longer than usual. These were strangers I would likely never see again. Without either of us knowing it in advance, this had been our last meeting.

If we looked at every person, every place, every ordinary thing around us, as though we were seeing it for the last time, something in us would change completely. We would stop hurrying past what we barely notice now. We would begin looking at everything, and everyone, with all the love we have. Let it be the most bleoved one in front of you!

_____________________________________________________________________

In short: A chance conversation with a stranger on a train, one where neither exchanged a name or a number, becomes the entry point into a philosophy the author calls the Last Meeting Theory. Drawing on the impermanence of a river, a flower, even a photograph, and echoing both Heraclitus and the Buddhist concept of anicca, the piece argues that every meeting with another person, however familiar, may be the only one of its kind, since the version of them present in that moment will never exist in quite that form again. It extends this beyond strangers to parents and children, the people we wrongly assume will always be available to us unchanged, and closes with a simple shift: looking at everyone and everything as though it were being seen for the last time.

The Last Meeting Theory Read More »

Thirty-Six Hours to Kakinada: What Indian Railways Still Owes Its Passengers

I was genuinely excited for this journey, the first long distance train trip I had made in years. There was a particular nostalgia in it too, a return to the era when the train, not the flight, was how a real journey felt. And this time the destination sharpened that excitement further. I was travelling to the state where I was born, decades ago, a place I had not returned to by rail in a very long time.

The train was scheduled for 5.05 in the evening. I reached the station by 4, only to learn it had been delayed by five hours, now expected at 10.05. Rather than sit at the station for six hours, I took a taxi back home and returned around 9.30, giving myself enough time to settle before boarding. It was only after I was back at the station that I heard the next announcement. The train would now arrive at 1.15 in the morning. I was carrying heavy luggage, and the idea of going home a second time and coming back again for a third made no sense. So I sat, at the station, for the hours that followed, and waited for a train that kept moving further away from the time I had planned my entire evening around. Since the day I booked, I have received a number of emails and messages from Indian Railway asking me if I need extra services, meals etc. I wonder why couldn’t they just send a message when the train was recheduled.

When it finally arrived and stopped, cleaning staff came aboard for a few minutes, going through motions that looked more like a performance of cleaning than the act itself. The compartment doors opened to very few passengers in Second AC. What greeted me inside was, without exaggeration, one of the worst coaches I have travelled in. Small insects, cockroach-like, moved along the berths and walls with no particular urgency, as though they, too, had come to expect this coach as their own. At some point during the journey, a mouse appeared, unhurried, crossing the floor of a coach I had paid a premium fare to travel in. This was Second AC, one of the higher tiers of Indian Railways travel, leaving aside Vande Bharat and its separate category entirely. I found myself wondering, seriously, what condition the sleeper and general compartments further down the same train must have been in, if this was what greeted a paying AC passenger. The coach itself, I noticed, was split down the middle, First AC on one side, Second AC on the other, sharing the same tired structure.

I do not fully know how I managed to sleep that night, given how far behind schedule the train already was and continued to fall. Tea, or anything resembling regular service, was rare, noticeably more so than on other trains I have taken. Through the night and into the following day, I watched the train pull into station after station, not to let passengers on or off, but simply to wait, stationary, while other trains were given priority to pass.

By early afternoon the next day, a middle aged co-passenger began walking the length of the compartment in visible panic. It emerged that his bag, containing his laptop, his essential documents, his cards, and the keys to his own home, had gone missing. He had been running a high fever through the journey and had fallen asleep with the bag kept close beside him, the way any exhausted, unwell traveller reasonably would. I remembered the train’s last stop, and a few passengers moving through the compartment around that time. Watching him search, increasingly certain of what had happened, was difficult to witness. I found myself quietly checking my own belongings, making sure everything I had brought was still where I had left it. No police official came to the compartment, not once, in the hours that followed. The entire episode ended exactly where these things usually end in this country, a complaint lodged over the telephone, filed into a system that, by every indication, would take it nowhere.

After roughly thirty six hours from departure to arrival, a journey that should have taken a fraction of that time, I reached Kakinada. The compartment, by then, was almost entirely empty.

I have read, like most Indians have, a great deal about the transformation supposedly underway in Indian Railways, the new trains, the modernised stations, the promise of a railway system finally catching up to the country it serves. I am not asking for that transformation to happen overnight. No reasonable person expects an institution this large to change in a season. But there is a difference between not yet having achieved excellence and failing, repeatedly, at the most basic things a paying passenger is owed. A clean coach without insects and rodents is not an aspiration. It is a baseline. What I experienced falls well short of even that baseline, in a class of travel positioned as one of the more comfortable options available.

Consider, then, what the general compartments carry, the ones I did not travel in but could only imagine after seeing my own. Passengers packed in with barely room to breathe, let alone sit comfortably for a journey of any real length. Toilets in those compartments that, by every account I have heard from others who have endured them, are conditions that would turn most stomachs on sight. If this is what a Second AC passenger is handed, I do not need much imagination to guess at what a general compartment traveller, who is very often the passenger with the least means to absorb such treatment, is left to endure.

And then there is security, or rather, its complete absence. A man loses his laptop, his cards, the very keys to his home, on a moving train he paid to travel on safely, and not a single official appears to even acknowledge it in person. The response is a phone number and a complaint that vanishes into a system with no accountability attached to it. Forget the bag. If a passenger loses something far more serious than belongings on that train, the response, I suspect, would look identical, a complaint registered, and nothing that follows it.

We have all heard the railway’s standard line by now, the inconvenience is regretted. I would like to ask, plainly, who is regretting what, exactly. Who compensates me for the taxi rides back and forth to a station that kept moving its own departure time by the hour. Who accounts for the time lost, an entire extra day and more of a finite life that no government, however efficient it eventually becomes, can ever hand back to a person once it is spent. I paid a real fare for this journey, priced as a premium class of travel. What, precisely, did that fare purchase. If it was not comfort, not safety, not punctuality, and not even basic cleanliness, I am left asking a simple question the railway owes every passenger an honest answer to: was this a fare, or simply a donation, handed over in exchange for nothing resembling the service it was meant to buy.

I stepped off the train at Kakinada in the early hours of the morning, the platform still half asleep, the air carrying that particular stillness only a very early morning arrival has. Thirty six hours after I had first reached the station in Mysore, filled with the excitement of a journey home, I was finally standing in the state where my life had begun, tired in a way that had very little to do with the actual distance travelled, and everything to do with everything that stood between the two points on the map.

In short: A long-awaited train journey from Mysore to Kakinada, meant to revive the nostalgia of travel by rail, turned into a 36-hour ordeal. A nine-hour delay, a filthy Second AC coach with cockroaches and a mouse, near-absent food service, and a fellow passenger whose laptop and house keys were stolen with no police response at all, only a phone complaint that led nowhere. The piece argues that despite years of railway PR about modernisation, the most basic passenger expectations, cleanliness, security, and punctuality, remain unmet, and asks plainly what a premium fare is actually paying for if not these.

Thirty-Six Hours to Kakinada: What Indian Railways Still Owes Its Passengers Read More »

Whispers Between the Lines: The Beauty of Rising Again

Our greatest glory is not in never falling, but in rising every time we fall. — Confucius

Life has a way of testing us when we least expect it. Just when everything seems to be falling into place, an unexpected setback can change the course of our lives. A cherished dream may crumble, a trusted relationship may falter, a career may take an unforeseen turn, or an illness may interrupt plans we have carefully made. In such moments, it is natural to ask, “Why me?” Perhaps, however, a more meaningful question is, “What can this experience teach me?”

Every life, no matter how successful it appears from the outside, carries unseen battles. Behind a smile may lie disappointment, silent tears, uncertainty, or a struggle that no one else knows about. Yet our difficulties do not have to define us. What matters is how we respond to them and how we allow them to make of us.

Consider the bamboo plant. For years, it grows quietly beneath the surface, strengthening its roots while showing little visible progress. To an impatient observer, it may seem that nothing is happening. Suddenly, it rises with remarkable speed. Its visible growth is possible because of the invisible foundation it patiently built for a long time.

Our lives often follow the same pattern. There are times when we feel unnoticed, unsuccessful, or left behind. We compare our journey with that of others and wonder whether our efforts are making a difference. But growth is not always visible. Some of life’s most important work takes place quietly within us, building patience, wisdom, resilience, and character. What feels like a season of waiting may actually be a season of preparation.

Failure, too, is not the opposite of success. It is often part of the journey towards it. Every mistake teaches us something that success may never reveal. Every disappointment can reshape our perspective, while every closed door may quietly redirect us towards a path we are not prepared to see before.

Think of a child learning to ride a bicycle. The child falls repeatedly, yet every fall teaches balance, courage and determination. If the child gave up after the first fall, the joy of riding would never be known. Life asks the same of us. Falling is natural. Rising again is a choice.

Resilience does not mean pretending to be strong all the time. It means allowing ourselves to feel pain without allowing pain to determine our future; knowing when to rest, seek help, and when to gather the courage to take another step. True strength is not found in never breaking; it is found in learning how to rebuild.

Perhaps someone reading this is carrying a burden that no one else knows about. If that is you, remember this: you have already survived every difficult day that has come before this one. The courage that carried you then, still lives within you now. Trust it. Nurture it. Let it guide you forward.

As you step into this new week, do not be afraid of life’s storms. They may bend you, but they can also strengthen your roots. Every challenge you overcome becomes part of your story-a story that may one day give someone else the courage to keep going.

Life is not about never falling. It is about discovering, again and again, the quiet strength to rise.

Reflection of the Week: The strongest people are not those who never face storms, but those who learn to dance in the rain while still looking for the sunrise.

Until next week, hold on to hope, believe in your inner strength, and remember: every sunrise is proof that darkness never has the final word, and every new beginning is an invitation to rise again.

Dr. Janatha Ramanathan

About the Author

Dr. Janatha Ramanathan is a poet, critic, translator, short story writer and columnist, and Associate Professor of English at Sree Ayyappa College for Women, Chunkankadai, Tamil Nadu. In two decades of teaching, she has published over eighty-five articles and presented ninety papers at national and international platforms, with particular scholarly focus on South African Literature.

She is Founder and Chief Editor of The Daffodils – An International Journal of Literature, Language and Criticism, and has edited seven anthologies of academic research and four poetry collections. Her own works, including her debut collection A Bundle of Joy, engage deeply with Indian, African American and Subaltern literatures.

Her honours include the Most Influential Women Award 2021 from the Writers Capital Foundation, Athens, and the Best Researcher Award from the University of Malaya, Malaysia.

Whispers Between the Lines: The Beauty of Rising Again Read More »